fantasy question/advice

[oaklandgm (A)]

so I am in a 16 team keeper league....we just had our draft the other day. Here is my roster after the draft

C- Matt Wieters--keeper
C- Miguel Olivo
1B- James Loney
1B- Yonder Alonso
2B- Jose Lopez
SS- Orlando Cabrera
3B- Mark Reynolds--keeper
3B- Mat Gamel
LF- Carlos Gonzalez--keeper
CF- Cameron Maybin--keeper
CF- Rajai Davis
RF- Cody Ross
OF- Gerardo Parra

SP- David Price--keeper
SP- Phil Hughes--keeper
SP- Madison Bumgarner--keeper
SP- Trevor Cahill--keeper
SP- Stephen Strasburg
SP- Aaron Crow
SP- Erik Bedard
SP- John Danks
SP- Travis Wood
SP- Kenshin Kawakami
RP- Francisco Rodriguez
RP- Takashi Saito

I kept 8 players, those that are noted. I got Strasburg, Alonso and Danks with my 9th, 10th and 11th round picks. Basically I am rebuilding....I've been offered a trade, and want your opinion...keep in mind this is a keeper league. Initially I declined this deal, but the guy is leaving it on the table

I would get:

C- Tyler Flowers
2B- Howie Kendrick
SS- Stephen Drew
SP- Jered Weaver
SP- Max Scherzer
1 of the following: James Shields, Joba Chamberlain, Logan Morrison

He would get:

C- Matt Wieters
OF- Carlos Gonzalez
whomever I throw in to even the deal up.....

While I would be adding a bit of talent to my team overall, I am too in love with the talent of Wieters and CarGo. What do you think?

[Red Sox GM]

What sort of scoring system do you use? 4x4, 5x5?

[TigersGM]

I would think if you made this deal Scherezer, Weaver, and Shields could end having better numbers than any current picther you have this year . . .

[guessy]

How many keepers do you get each year?

[oaklandgm (A)]

you can keep up to 12, but lately I've just been keeping 8, and I usually have one of the top picks and the high waiver.....as for scoring, there are different categories:

runs, 1b, 2b, 3b, HR, RBI, SB, BB, BA, OBP, SLG
IP, W, L, Svs, BB, K, Hld, ERA, WHIP, K/BB, K/9

I should also add to this that Yahoo has added almost every top prospect, so the waiver priority isn't going to make that much of a difference

[oaklandgm (A)]

now he is adding dominic brown but taking away Stephen drew

[Yankees GM (A)]

I like your two players more than anything he's throwing up there so I'd say no.

[oaklandgm (A)]

That is my thought, that my 2 are more talented than anything he is offering....what if I could get Drew, Scherzer, Weaver, Dom Brown, and Kendrick, would you do that?

[TigersGM]

you could also try to upgrade a future draft pick as well . . .you know like added in a 4th next year for a 2nd

[oaklandgm (A)]

ok, new development to the deal

Would you do

Jon Lester
Tyler Flowers
Max Scherzer
Dom Brown
and 1 more of Delmon Young, Logan Morrison, Howie Kendrick, Stephen Drew

for Wieters and CarGo

[guessy]

I say that Wieters and Carlos Gonzalez are much better then what you are getting.